Treasure Island vs Yerba Buena Island: Two Islands, Two Very Different Ways to Live

Treasure Island vs Yerba Buena Island: Two Islands, Two Very Different Ways to Live

From the Bay Bridge, it’s easy to assume Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island offer the same experience.

They don’t.

While they share geography, the lifestyle on each island is fundamentally different — and choosing between them says a lot about how you want to live day to day.

Yerba Buena Island: Elevated and Private

Yerba Buena Island appeals to buyers who value seclusion. Homes are tucked into the hillside, surrounded by trees, with dramatic elevation and sweeping views. It feels removed — intentionally so.

For some, that retreat-like atmosphere is the draw. For others, it can feel isolating.

Treasure Island: Walkable, Social, Alive

Treasure Island is flat, open, and connected. You don’t need to plan a drive to leave your house — you walk out the door.

Morning strolls along the water. Neighbors chatting on the promenade. Coffee before the ferry. Sunset with the skyline glowing across the Bay.

It’s a lifestyle that unfolds outdoors and among people.

Convenience Changes Everything

Treasure Island’s ferry access, future retail village, marina, and parks mean daily life happens close to home. Errands don’t feel like logistics. Social moments happen organically.

The difference isn’t better or worse — it’s energy.

Yerba Buena Island is a retreat.
Treasure Island is a neighborhood.

Choosing the Island That Fits You

If you want privacy above all else, Yerba Buena Island may be your place.

If you want connection — to the city, to nature, to other people — Treasure Island offers something uniquely rare in San Francisco: community without congestion.

‍